Why Award Titles Matter More Than You Think
Think of being awarded "Employee of the Year" in contrast to being awarded "The Trailblazer Award". Both are awards of excellence, but something feels completely different. One seems official and even may feel somewhat expected, while the other feels invigorating - it tells a story and encourages you to stand just a little taller.
When we think about employee recognition, we often focus on the tangible: the weight of the trophy, the elegance of the engraving, the shine of the material. And yes, these elements matter. But there's something equally powerful that often gets overlooked—the language we use, particularly the title of the award itself.
The term we select to honour achievement has an important psychological impact on the receipt, memory, and action taken in recognition of achievement. A well-conceived award title does more than label accomplishment; it increases motivation, develops identity, and fosters pride that lasts. This article will reflect on how the award title selected can change recognition from a momentary experience into a ripple for future continued excellence.
The Psychology Behind Recognition and Motivation
As human beings, we have an emotional response to acknowledgement. Acknowledging is not just "I know I did well." Acknowledging relates to "I feel valued for my contribution." This is where language is paramount. The specific words we receive do stimulate certain emotional responses that inform our thoughts regarding our performance.
Consider these two examples:
-
"Excellence Award" → The focus lands squarely on achievement and quality
-
"Game Changer Award" → The emphasis shifts to impact, innovation, and transformation
Both are good, but they have different meanings. The first recognises doing something effectively, and the second recognises doing something that mattered, that shifted the landscape. Just that subtle difference changes everything about how the recipient personally acknowledges their success.
Studies in organisational psychology repeatedly indicate that individuals have a deeper relationship to recognition that is personal and purpose-driven. General titles can feel transactional, as if you are checking a box. Intentional titles become emotional anchors that recipients carry with them long after the event.
How Award Titles Influence Perception
They Shape Identity
Award titles uniquely shape winners' future self-view. When someone receives a title like "Leader of the Year," it's more than acknowledgement—it's a catalyst for sustaining their leadership identity. It becomes part of their professional story—their decisions and behaviours become the lens to the title and awards.
This emotional attachment leads to measurable results: greater loyalty, deeper engagement, and a real desire to embody the expectations of the award in the future. The right title doesn't just recognise who someone was; it moves people to actualise who they can become.
They Reflect Company Culture
Every award title is a statement about what your organisation values. The names you choose communicate priorities louder than any mission statement on a wall.
Think about "The Collaborator's Cup" against "Top Sales Performer". Both reward a fantastic contribution, but they reward completely different behaviours. The first rewards collaborative behaviour, engagement, and shared success, while the second is focused on individual performance, and the excellence of competition. You don't have to be wrong about how you recognise contribution, but you can understand the language you are sending about what your culture values.
When award titles align with authentic organisational values, they reinforce the behaviours you want to see repeated across your teams.
They Enhance Storytelling
In today's workplace, recognition isn't just a private moment—it's a story worth sharing. Whether it's an announcement in a company newsletter, a post on social media, or a speech at an annual gala, award titles that tell a story are infinitely more memorable.
Take "The Spark Award" as an example. Immediately, you imagine ignition, inspiration, someone who lit a fire under a project or a team. It's visual, emotional, and easy to celebrate. Compare that to "Outstanding Achievement Award"—accurate, but forgettable. The former invites narrative; the latter just states a fact.
A well-chosen name becomes a talking point, something people remember and aspire toward.
Elements of a Strong and Motivating Award Title
Not every creative title is an effective one. The best award names balance several key qualities:
1. Make it simple: It should be clear, immediately. If people ask you what it means, you have robbed it of any impact before they can even get to the explanation.
2. Make it relevant: The title should speak to, and be legitimately connected to, the behaviour/change you are recognising someone for. No one appreciates forced cleverness.
3. Make it emotional: Does it create pride? Or a sense of belonging? Or excitement? If it doesn't create an emotional reaction, it is just words on a plaque.
4. Make it creative: This is your opportunity to differentiate from all of the hundreds of "Employee of the Month" plaques sitting on doors collecting dust. Don't be afraid to be creative.
5. Make it inclusive: Avoid language that might feel alienating or corporate, or cold. The objective of the exercise is to make people feel seen, not categorised.
Real-World Examples & Inspiration
If you're looking for a starting point, here are a few creative award title ideas and the types of recognition they suit:
-
The Growth Catalyst Award: This is ideal for an individual who embodies development, mentors others, or can move the organisation or team forward through continuous improvement.
-
The Unstoppable Spirit Award: This is ideal for individuals who enjoy being resilient or allow their persistence to shine through a sense of stability during challenges, or continue to be committed through challenges
-
The Next Horizon Award: This is ideal for those who are innovators, forward-thinkers or visionaries who help to keep our organisation open to new horizons and possibilities.
-
The Culture Champion Award: This award is for individuals who live out and exemplify the company values through activity, engagement, and a positive environment.
Each of these titles does more than describe an action—they evoke a feeling and tell a story about the person being honoured.
The Role of Award Design in Supporting the Title
Language and design come together here. A strong title deserves a design that supports and enhances that title. When the physical award is designed to represent the emotion behind the title, it creates a total experience.
For example, "The Trailblazer Award" could incorporate flame graphics, the path etched into the base, or a design that suggests movement and exploration. "The Pillar Award" may include solid vertical lines and an overall foundation focus. When, in naming the award, language and imagery support one another, a phrase becomes instantly memorable and tangible.
At RD Custom Awards, we take this alignment seriously! We collaborate with our clients from the beginning of the award process to ensure the design is not just a trophy with a title; it becomes the title. The educational moment is when someone gets an award, and you can feel the energy when every aspect of the award resonates with the message.
Words That Inspire, Awards That Last
The proper award title has an amazing effect; it provides meaning that goes far beyond the immediate recognition. It takes recognition and develops into identity, excellence into a goal.
If you are developing or refining a recognition program, be sure you go beyond generic award titles. Consider the behaviours you are trying to encourage, the culture you are developing, and the narrative you want to live on in your people.
Because here's the thing: the title of an award is not simply a title. It is a legacy in words, a reminder of the impact that was made, or the potential impact still to come. Choose the words carefully, and you will not only maintain excellence; you will create it.
